跳至主要内容

如何解读分歧

A substance prohibited in one market and permitted under conditions in another is not a contradiction to be resolved. Each position is correct in its own jurisdiction, and a product sold in both must satisfy the stricter one.

  • 210 substances are classified differently by the markets that hold a rule for them.
  • 127 of those are prohibited in at least one market and permitted in another.
  • A market absent from a comparison has no imported rule here; that is not evidence it permits the substance.
  • Where a market holds two rules at once, its position depends on the use, and both are shown.

The disagreements on this page are not errors. Each regulator reached its position through its own procedure, on its own evidence, at its own date, and each is correct where it applies. What the comparison shows is that "is this ingredient allowed" has no single answer once a product crosses a border.

Most divergence has one of three ordinary causes. The first is timing: a restriction adopted in the EU propagates to markets that mirror EU law, but not simultaneously, so for a period the same substance is restricted in one and unrestricted in another purely because an amendment has not been transposed yet. The second is instrument: some markets legislate by prohibition list, others by positive list, and a substance's absence means opposite things under the two — unlisted is permitted by default under a prohibition list and forbidden by default under a positive list. The third is scope: a rule may bite only for a particular product category, concentration or route of exposure, so a market that prohibits a substance in leave-on products and permits it in rinse-off appears in both columns at once.

For anyone formulating, the practical consequence is simple and uncomfortable: a single formula sold across several of these markets is governed by the strictest position among them, not by the average and not by the market it was designed for. A substance permitted at 1% in one place and prohibited in another cannot be used at all in a product shipped to both, unless the formula is split by market — which is a commercial decision, not a regulatory one.

Read a row here as a starting point, never as the finding. The status words compress a rule that may run to several conditions, and the concentration limits, product-type restrictions and warning requirements that decide compliance live in the individual records. Every market named links to the rule it came from, and every rule to the official source it was read from; that chain, rather than the summary, is what a regulatory file needs.

核对依据

跨市场

化妆品市场分歧之处

同一种物质可能因产品销售地不同而受到不同的监管。本页列出本站跟踪的 13 个市场中立场不一的 210 种物质,影响最大者排在前面。

仅当某市场已导入相应规则时才会列出该市场。某行中缺少某市场并不证明该市场准许该物质——这只表示本站没有该配对的规则,仍须核查官方来源。

“限用”和“列入准用清单”是不同的制度工具,不会合并:获准用于指定用途的着色剂,与在浓度限值以下允许使用的物质并不相同。

已对比的物质
210
在某处禁用,在别处准用
127

逐一物质

Diethylene Glycol冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANChinaSouth KoreaAustraliaBrazilIndiaSaudi Arabia
限用
Canada

Great Britain 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 New Zealand 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 India 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 Saudi Arabia 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Oxyquinoline冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANChinaSouth KoreaBrazilIndiaSaudi Arabia
限用
Canada

New Zealand 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 ASEAN 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

1-NAPHTHOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainCanadaNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Formaldehyde冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANChinaSouth KoreaIndiaSaudi Arabia
限用
Canada

ASEAN 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hydroquinone冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANChinaSouth KoreaIndiaSaudi Arabia
限用
Canada

Great Britain 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 New Zealand 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 ASEAN 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 India 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 Saudi Arabia 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

1,5-NAPHTHALENEDIOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2,7-NAPHTHALENEDIOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-AMINO-6-CHLORO-4-NITROPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-METHYLRESORCINOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

3-NITRO-P-HYDROXYETHYLAMINOPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-AMINO-2-HYDROXYTOLUENE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-AMINO-3-NITROPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-AMINO-M-CRESOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

M-AMINOPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

P-PHENYLENEDIAMINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainCanadaNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Phenyl Methyl Pyrazolone冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANAustraliaIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

TOLUENE-2,5-DIAMINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainCanadaNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Zinc Pyrithione冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainSaudi Arabia
限用
New ZealandASEANJapanSouth KoreaIndia

New Zealand 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。 ASEAN 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

1,3-BIS-(2,4-DIAMINOPHENOXY)PROPANE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

1-HYDROXYETHYL 4,5-DIAMINO Pyrazole Sulfate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2,6-DIAMINOPYRIDINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2,6-DIHYDROXYETHYLAMINOTOLUENE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-AMINO-3-HYDROXYPYRIDINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-AMINO-4-HYDROXYETHYLAMINOANISOLE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-CHLORO-6-ETHYLAMINO-4-NITROPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-HYDROXYETHYL Picramic Acid冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-HYDROXYETHYLAMINO-5-NITROANISOLE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2-METHYL-5-HYDROXYETHYLAMINOPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

3-AMINO-2,4-DICHLOROPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

3-METHYLAMINO-4-NITROPHENOXYETHANOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-HYDROXYPROPYLAMINO-3-NITROPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-NITRO-O-PHENYLENEDIAMINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

4-NITROPHENYL Aminoethylurea冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

5-AMINO-6-CHLORO-O-CRESOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

6-HYDROXYINDOLE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

6-METHOXY-2-METHYLAMINO-3-AMINOPYRIDINE Hcl冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Dihydroxyindoline冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Blue No. 2冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Red No. 13冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Violet No. 1冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Violet No. 2冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Yellow No. 10冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hydroxybenzomorpholine冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

HYDROXYETHYL-2-NITRO-P-TOLUIDINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

HYDROXYETHYL-3,4-METHYLENEDIOXYANILINE Hcl冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

N,N-BIS(2-HYDROXYETHYL)-P-PHENYLENEDIAMINE Sulfate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

P-AMINOPHENOL冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Picramic Acid冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Trimethylbenzoyl Diphenylphosphine Oxide冲突

禁用
European UnionGreat BritainBrazilSaudi Arabia
限用
New ZealandASEANIndia

Great Britain 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

2,6-DIMETHOXY-3,5-PYRIDINEDIAMINE Hcl冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Orange No. 2冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionGreat BritainNew ZealandASEANIndia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Hc Red No. 10冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionNew ZealandASEANIndiaSaudi Arabia

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Oxyquinoline Sulfate冲突

禁用
European UnionNew Zealand
限用
Great BritainIndiaSaudi Arabia

New Zealand 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Sodium Picramate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionCanadaNew Zealand

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

CI 12120冲突

禁用
Canada
列入准用清单
European UnionNew Zealand

CI 77266冲突

禁用
South Korea
列入准用清单
European UnionNew Zealand

Gold冲突

禁用
European Union
列入准用清单
Great BritainNew Zealand

M-AMINOPHENOL Sulfate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionNew Zealand

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

P-PHENYLENEDIAMINE Hcl冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionNew Zealand

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

P-PHENYLENEDIAMINE Sulfate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionNew Zealand

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Sodium Iodate冲突

禁用
China
限用
South Korea
列入准用清单
European Union

TOLUENE-2,5-DIAMINE Sulfate冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European UnionNew Zealand

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

N-PHENYL-P-PHENYLENEDIAMINE冲突

禁用
South Korea
限用
European Union

South Korea 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Triclosan

限用
CanadaASEANSouth KoreaAustralia
列入准用清单
European UnionGreat BritainNew Zealand

ASEAN 对该物质有多条规则,因此其立场取决于具体用途。

Cinoxate

限用
JapanSouth Korea
列入准用清单
New Zealand

BENZOPHENONE-8

限用
South Korea
列入准用清单
New Zealand

Citric Acid

限用
Canada
列入准用清单
European Union