How to Check Cosmetic Product Claims Against an Ingredient List
Check the wording, formula version and test outcome behind a cosmetic claim. Work through a claim about the finished product versus one about an ingredient.
Write down the words from the box or product page, with the brand, variant and source date. A statement about containing an ingredient and a claim about a result need different evidence. The wording matters. “Contains glycerin” is easier to check from a label than “keeps hands moisturised for 24 hours.”
Check the ingredient declaration
Read the package for the version you intend to buy. Search the complete name using CosIng Checker (https://cosingchecker.com/search/) and confirm the spelling or identity. If the front names a group or concept, check which specific ingredient names are on the back. A generic database function describes an ingredient role. Keep a separate note of the product claim and what supports it.
Ask for evidence behind measurable claims
For an effect stated over a particular time, useful details include the product tested, the group studied, the method used and the time of measurement. An ingredient study might give context. Check whether the evidence supplied actually covers the same product and stated result.
Write a short, verifiable conclusion
For the sample claims, a reviewer could write: “The package lists Glycerin. I did not find details of a 24-hour test for this version.” That states the scope of the check and what remains open. For a professional review, retain the source and the evidence requested from the supplier or brand.
Official source
The EU common criteria for cosmetic claims include truthfulness and evidential support. See Commission Regulation 655/2013 (https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/en/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32013R0655)
Three fields make a claim check reproducible
Record the precise wording, the evidence supplied, and what that evidence measured. For a “contains glycerin” claim, the package can show the declared name. For a duration or quantified performance claim, identify the product tested and the conditions. A useful summary states which finding is confirmed and which still needs supporting evidence.
Compare a presence claim and a measurable claim
Suppose a retailer says a hand cream contains Glycerin and also promises hydration for a named duration. Look for Glycerin in the actual declaration and record the package variant. Then identify any product-specific study or data given for the duration claim. Write down whether it names the exact product, how the result was measured, and the duration or timing that was actually evaluated.
If all you can find is an inventory definition or a supplier sheet on glycerin, describe its scope when reporting it. It can help identify the ingredient and its possible function. Evaluate a finished-product claim with evidence for that product and intended use. When the brand answers a question, record the date and retain its wording instead of extending it to other formulas in the range.
Related records and guides: Glycerin · Cosmetic ingredient lookup.
Example: a percentage claim and a wear claim need different evidence
Suppose a package says “with 5% moisturizing complex” and “comfortable all day.” Record the two claims separately. For the first, identify what the percentage describes and seek the basis if it is not stated. For the second, check whether the maker assessed the marketed formula under a relevant use pattern and what outcome it recorded. A matching ingredient name helps identify the material but cannot prove an all-day result. See what the EU ingredient order cannot tell you about percentages and the EU common criteria for cosmetic claims for the distinction between ingredient properties and finished-product evidence.
Save enough to check the answer later
If the listing has no date or formula version, take a screenshot and ask which size and market the evidence covers. Compare the actual declarations via the formula comparison tool if the seller sends details for two versions.
Before using a testimonial as claim evidence
A review that says “my skin felt less tight” records one person’s experience. A claim such as “reduces dryness for 24 hours” adds a duration and a defined outcome that require their own support. Ask the brand for the tested version, observation time, outcome and comparison, if one was used. If the company publishes only a result from a supplier, check which material and formula that report covers. A retailer writing a description can keep buyer impressions alongside the exact supported claim, with the source and date visible. For an EU claim review, start with the EU common criteria for cosmetic claims.
이 글 소개
이 글은 EU 화장품 원료, 부속서 II–VI 제한 사항, 경고 문구, 보존제, 자외선 차단 성분, 색소 및 관련 규제 준수 주제에 대한 가이드, 노트 및 실용적인 해설을 게시하는 CosIng Checker 블로그의 일부입니다.