본문으로 건너뛰기
NZEnglish제공되는 공식 기록

New Zealand 화장품 원료 규정

Official group-standard schedules cover prohibited, restricted and positive-list substances.

규제 기관
Environmental Protection Authority
출처 언어
English
적용 범위 버전
Cosmetic Products Group Standard schedules effective 1 January 2026

이 목록의 의미

New Zealand regulates cosmetics as hazardous substances. The rules sit in a group standard issued by the Environmental Protection Authority, not in a cosmetics act, and the schedules read differently as a result.

  • 2,913 New Zealand records: 2,166 prohibited, 390 restricted, 357 on a positive list.
  • The instrument is the Cosmetic Products Group Standard, made under the Hazardous Substances and New Organisms Act.
  • The regulator is the Environmental Protection Authority, not a medicines or food agency.
  • Schedules 4 to 8 mirror the EU annex structure closely, which makes the divergences easy to miss.

New Zealand reaches cosmetics through hazardous-substances law. The Cosmetic Products Group Standard, issued under the Hazardous Substances and New Organisms Act, sets the conditions under which cosmetic products may be imported or manufactured, and the Environmental Protection Authority administers it. There is no separate cosmetics regulator.

In substance the schedules will look familiar: schedules 4 through 8 are laid out much like the EU annexes, with prohibited substances, restricted substances and positive lists for colourants, preservatives and UV filters. That resemblance is the risk. Because the structure matches, it is easy to assume the contents do, and the group standard is amended on its own schedule by its own authority.

The 2,913 records here carry the status the group standard gives them. Where a substance appears as restricted, the limit and conditions are as written in the schedule; where a substance does not appear, no New Zealand entry was resolved for it, which is not the same as a finding that it may be used.

대조 대상

공식 원료 기록

2913 일치하는 기록
Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium bromide

CAS 91080-29-4 · EC 293-522-5

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 136 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium bromide

CAS 91080-29-4 · EC 293-522-5

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 87 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 8001-54-5 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 130 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 63449-41-2 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 131 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 68424-85-1 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 132 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 85409-22-9 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 133 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 68391-01-5 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 134 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 61789-71-7 · EC 263-080-8

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 135 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 63449-41-2 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 89 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 68391-01-5 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 90 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 68424-85-1 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 91 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium chloride

CAS 85409-22-9 · EC 264-151-6 / 269-919-4 / 270-325-2 / 287-089-1

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 92 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium saccharinate

CAS 68989-01-5 · EC 273-545-7

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 54.

조건: Maximum concentration: 0.1% calculated as benzalkonium chloride · Warnings: Avoid contact with eyes.

출처:Schedule 7, reference 54, source row 137 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzalkonium saccharinate

CAS 68989-01-5 · EC 273-545-7

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 65.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off hair (head) care products (b) Other products · Maximum concentration: (a) 3% (as benzalkonium chloride) (b) 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Other limitations: (a) and (b): In the final products the concentrations of benzalkonium chloride, bromide and saccharinate with an alkyl chain of C14 or less must not exceed 0.1% (as benzalkonium chloride) · Warnings: For (a) and (b): Avoid contact with the eyes.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 65, source row 88 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenaminium, 3-[(4,5-dihydro-3-methyl-5-oxo-1-phenyl-1H-pyrazol-4-yl)azo]-N,N,N-trimethyl chloride (Basic Yellow 57)

CAS 68391-31-1 · EC 269-943-5

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 262.

조건: Product scope: Hair dye substance in non-oxidative hair dye products · Maximum concentration: 2%

출처:Schedule 5, reference 262, source row 317 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

ProhibitedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenaminium, 3-[[4-[[diamino(phenylazo)phenyl]azo]-1-naphthalenyl]azo]-N,N,N-trimethyl and its salts, when used as a substance in hair dye products

CAS 83803-98-9 · EC 280-919-3

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 4, reference 1298.

출처:Schedule 4, reference 1298, source row 1353 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

ProhibitedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenaminium, 3-[[4-[[diamino(phenylazo)phenyl]azo]-2-methylphenyl]azo]-N,N,N-trimethyl and its salts, when used as a substance in hair dye products

CAS 83803-99-0 · EC 280-920-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 4, reference 1297.

출처:Schedule 4, reference 1297, source row 1352 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzene-methanaminium, N-ethyl-N-(4-((4-(ethyl((3-sulfophenyl)​methyl)amino)phenyl)(2-sulfo​phenyl)methylene)-2,5-cyclohexa​dien-1-ylidene)-3-sulfo-, hydroxide, inner salt, disodium salt (Acid Blue 9)

CAS 3844-45-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 6, reference 63.

조건: Colour index: 42090 · CAS: 3844-45-9 · Colour: Blue

출처:Schedule 6, reference 63, source row 65 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzene-methanaminium, N-ethyl-N-(4-((4-(ethyl((3-sulfophenyl)​methyl)amino)phenyl)(4-hydroxy-2-sulfophenyl)methylene)-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene)-3-sulfo-, hydroxide, inner salt, disodium salt (Food Green 3)

CAS 2353-45-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 6, reference 61.

조건: Colour index: 42053 · CAS: 2353-45-9 · Colour: Green

출처:Schedule 6, reference 61, source row 63 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenediamine, 2-(methoxy​methyl)-, sulfate (2-methoxy-methyl-p-phenylene-diamine sulfate)

CAS 337906-37-3 · EC 638-749-6

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 292.

조건: Product scope: (a) Hair dye substance in oxidative hair dye products (b) Products intended for colouring eyelashes · Maximum concentration: (a) and (b): After mixing under oxidative conditions the maximum concentration applied to hair or eyelashes must not exceed 1.8% (calculated as free base) · Other limitations: (b) For professional use only · Warnings: For (a): The mixing ratio. ⚠Hair colourants can cause severe allergic reactions. Read and follow instructions. This product is not intended for use on persons under the age of 16. Temporary “black henna” tattoos may increase your risk of allergy. Do not colour your hair if: - you have a rash on your face or sensitive, irritated and damaged scalp, - you have ever experienced any reaction after colouring your hair, - you have experienced a reaction to a temporary “black henna” tattoo in the past. For (b): The mixing ratio. For professional use only. ⚠This product can cause severe allergic reactions. Read and follow instructions. This product is not intended for use on persons under the age of 16. Temporary “black henna” tattoos may increase your risk of allergy. Eyelashes shall not be coloured if the consumer: - has a rash on the face or sensitive, irritated and damaged scalp, - has experienced any reaction after colouring your hair, - has experienced a reaction to a temporary “black henna” tattoo in the past. Rinse eyes immediately if product comes into contact with them.

출처:Schedule 5, reference 292, source row 354 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenemethanaminium, N,N-dimethyl-N-[2-[2-[4-(1,1,3,3,-tetramethylbutyl)phenoxy]ethoxy]​ethyl]-, chloride (benzethonium chloride)

CAS 121-54-0 · EC 204-479-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 7, reference 53.

조건: Product scope: (a) Rinse-off products only (b) Leave-on products other than for oral care use · Maximum concentration: 0.1%

출처:Schedule 7, reference 53, source row 129 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

ProhibitedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-(4-((4-(ethyl((3-sulfophenyl)methyl)amino)phenyl)(4-hydroxy-2-sulfophenyl)methylene)-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene)-3-sulfo-, hydroxide, inner salt, disodium salt (Fast Green FCF; CI 42053) when used as a substance in hair dye products

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-(4-((4-(ethyl((3-sulfophenyl)methyl)amino)phenyl)(4-hydroxy-2-sulfophenyl)methylene)-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene)-3-sulfo-, hydroxide, inner salt, disodium salt (Fast Green FCF; CI 42053) when used as a substance in hair dy

CAS 2353-45-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 4, reference 1357.

출처:Schedule 4, reference 1357, source row 1436 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt; Acid Blue 9 aluminium lake; CI 42090)

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt;

CAS 3844-45-9

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 190.

조건: Product scope: Hair dye substance in non-oxidative hair dye products · Maximum concentration: 0.5%

출처:Schedule 5, reference 190, source row 225 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt; Acid Blue 9 aluminium lake; CI 42090)

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt;

CAS 2650-18-2

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 190.

조건: Product scope: Hair dye substance in non-oxidative hair dye products · Maximum concentration: 0.5%

출처:Schedule 5, reference 190, source row 226 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

RestrictedBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt; Acid Blue 9 aluminium lake; CI 42090)

Benzenemethanaminium, N-ethyl-N-[4-[[4-[ethyl-[(3-sulfophenyl)-methyl]-amino]-phenyl] [2-sulfophenyl)-methylene]-2,5-cyclohexadien-1-ylidene]-3-sulfo, inner salt, disodium salt and its ammonium and aluminium salts* (Acid Blue 9; Acid Blue 9 Ammonium salt;

CAS 68921-42-6 · EC 272-939-6

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 5, reference 190.

조건: Product scope: Hair dye substance in non-oxidative hair dye products · Maximum concentration: 0.5%

출처:Schedule 5, reference 190, source row 227 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

Permitted list with conditionsBinding ruleOriginal is English공식 출처 가져오기 확인됨

Benzenesulfonic acid, 2,2'-(1,2-ethenediyl)bis[5-nitro-, disodium salt, reaction products with 4-[(4-aminophenyl)azo]benzenesulfonic acid, sodium salts (Direct Orange 34)

CAS 1325-54-8

New Zealand Cosmetic Products Group Standard Schedule 6, reference 54.

조건: Colour index: 40215 · CAS: 1325-54-8 · Colour: Orange · Product scope: Rinse-off products

출처:Schedule 6, reference 54, source row 56 · 버전 effective-2026-01-01 · 시행 2026년 1월 1일 · 출처 확인 2026-08-30

시장 적용 범위 계약

Complete schedules dataset
포함 범위
Schedules 4–8: prohibited, restricted, colourant, preservative and UV-filter entries.
일치하는 항목이 없는 경우
The searchable spreadsheet is an aid; the legal Group Standard and incorporated notices remain authoritative.

전체 확인 체크리스트

  1. Search exact identity across Schedules 4–8.
  2. Apply use, concentration and warning conditions.
  3. Check hazardous-substance classification and Group Standard scope.
  4. Confirm the latest legal instrument, not only the spreadsheet.

New Zealand이(가) 다른 시장과 다른 점

이 시장에서 가져온 규칙을 동일한 물질에 대한 다른 모든 시장의 규칙과 비교합니다. 물질에 대해 가져온 규칙이 없는 시장은 허용하는 것으로 취급되지 않고 해당 비교에서 제외됩니다.

공식 출처 및 법적 역할

New Zealand cosmetic product schedules 4–8

Prohibited and restricted substances, permitted colorants, preservatives and UV filters

법적 의미: Official EPA group standard schedules; current market-specific rule source

제공 언어: English

이 시장 페이지가 답할 수 있는 것

출처 및 권위

공식 자료와 이를 담당하는 규제 기관을 확인하세요: Environmental Protection Authority.

언어 및 범위

사용 가능한 영문 또는 이중 언어 자료가 있는지, 매핑된 출처가 실제로 무엇을 다루는지 확인하세요. 현재 출처 언어: English.

근거 상태

공식 출처에서 가져온 원료 단위 기록을 둘러보세요. 각 행에는 결정론적 출처 검사를 통과했는지 또는 사람의 편집 검토를 거쳤는지가 표시됩니다.

이 시장에서 원료를 확인하는 방법

  1. INCI 명칭, CAS 번호 또는 EC 번호로 원료를 검색하고 정확한 정체를 기록하세요.
  2. 위의 각 공식 출처를 열어 현행 버전, 제품 범위, 농도 한도 및 필수 경고 문구를 확인하세요.
  3. 시행일과 영문 텍스트가 공식, 검토됨 또는 참고용에 불과한지 확인하세요.
  4. 일치하는 항목이 없는 것은 알 수 없음으로 취급하고, 허용이나 안전성에 대한 결론으로 취급하지 마세요.