South Korea réglementation des ingrédients cosmétiques
The Korean source remains canonical; English-only material is incomplete.
- Autorité de réglementation
- Ministry of Food and Drug Safety
- Langue de la source
- Korean with some English names
- Version de la couverture
- MFDS Notice 2026-19, effective 18 March 2026
Ce qu’est cette liste
South Korea's cosmetic ingredient rules are published by the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety in Korean. The English material that circulates is partial, and the gaps are not marked.
- 1,320 Korean records: 1,077 prohibited, 243 restricted.
- The regulator is the Ministry of Food and Drug Safety, under the Cosmetics Act.
- The Korean text is canonical; English versions are incomplete rather than merely later.
- Functional cosmetics — sunscreen, whitening, anti-wrinkle and others — carry a separate reporting or approval route.
The Ministry of Food and Drug Safety maintains the prohibited and restricted ingredient lists under the Cosmetics Act, and publishes them in Korean. This matters more than the usual caution about translations. The English material in circulation is not a delayed version of the Korean; it is a subset, and nothing in it indicates which entries were left out.
The second thing to know is that Korea separates ordinary cosmetics from functional cosmetics. A product claiming sun protection, skin whitening, anti-wrinkle action, hair loss relief and several other functions falls into the functional category, which carries its own reporting or approval requirement and its own constraints on ingredients and concentrations. A formula that is unremarkable as a cosmetic can move into that category on the strength of a single claim.
The 1,320 records here come from the Korean source. Where a substance has no Korean record, that is the absence of an entry we could resolve, not a finding about the substance.
Vérifié par rapport à
Fiches officielles d’ingrédients
1320 fiches correspondantes2-[(2-메톡시-4-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올 및 그염류
CAS 66095-81-6 · EC 266-138-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 비산화염모제에 0.2% · 기타제품에는 사용금지 · 2-[(2-메톡시-4-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올(2-하이드록시에칠아미노-5-니트로아니솔)
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-228 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(3-아미노-4-메톡시페닐)아미노]에탄올 및 그 염류(예 : 2-아미노-4-하이드록시에칠아미노아니솔)1)
CAS 83763-47-7; 83763-48-8 · EC 280-733-2
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-아미노-4-하이드록시에칠아미노아니솔2-아미노-4-하이드록시에칠아미노아니솔설페이트
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-594 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(3-아미노-4-메톡시페닐)아미노]에탄올 및 그염류
CAS 83763-47-7 · EC 280-733-2
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 산화염모제에 1.5% · 기타제품에는 사용금지 · 2-아미노-4-하이드록시에칠아미노아니솔
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-236 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(4-아미노-2-메칠-5-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올 및 그 염류(예 : 에이치시자색 No. 1)1)
CAS 82576-75-8 · EC 417-600-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-[(4-아미노-2-메칠-5-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-593 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(4-아미노-2-메칠-5-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올및 그 염류
CAS 82576-75-8 · EC 417-600-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : ·산화염모제에 0.25% ·비산화염모제에 0.28% · 기타제품에는 사용금지 · 에이치시 자색No. 1
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-235 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(4-클로로-2-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올(에이치시 황색 No. 12) 및 그 염류
CAS 59320-13-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-[(4-클로로-2-니트로페닐)아미노]에탄올(에이치시 황색 No.12)
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-896 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[(4-클로로-2-니트로페닐)아조)-N-(2-메톡시페닐)-3-옥소부탄올아마이드(피그먼트옐로우 73) 및 그염류
CAS 13515-40-7 · EC 236-852-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-[(4-클로로-2-니트로페닐)아조)-N-(2-메톡시페닐)-3-옥소부탄올아마이드
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-897 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[2-하이드록시-3-(2-클로로페닐)카르바모일-1-나프틸아조]-7-[2-하이드록시-3-(3-메칠페닐)카르바모일-1-나프틸아조]플루오렌-9-온
CAS 151798-26-4
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-1236 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[3-(메칠아미노)-4-니트로페녹시]에탄올 및 그 염류 (예 : 3-메칠아미노-4-니트로페녹시에탄올)1)
CAS 59820-63-2 · EC 261-940-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 3-메칠아미노-4-니트로페녹시에탄올
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-295 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[3-(메칠아미노)-4-니트로페녹시]에탄올 및 그염류
CAS 59820-63-2 · EC 261-940-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 비산화염모제에 0.15% · 기타제품에는 사용금지 · 3-메칠아미노-4-니트로페녹시에탄올
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-224 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[[(4-메톡시페닐)메칠하이드라조노]메칠]-1,3,3-트리메칠-3H-인돌리움 및그 염류
CAS 54060-92-3 · EC 258-946-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-[[(4-메톡시페닐)메칠하이드라조노]메칠]-1,3,3-트리메칠-3H-인돌리움
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-347 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-[[4-[에칠(2-하이드록시에칠)아미노]페닐]아조]-6-메톡시-3-메칠-벤조치아졸리움 및 그 염류
CAS 12270-13-2 · EC 235-546-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-[[4-[에칠(2-하이드록시에칠)아미노]페닐]아조]-6-메톡시-3-메칠-벤조치아졸리움
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-743 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-{4-(2-암모니오프로필아미노)-6-[4-하이드록시-3-(5-메칠-2-메톡시-4-설파모일페닐아조)-2-설포네이토나프트-7-일아미노]-1,3,5-트리아진-2-일아미노}-2-아미노프로필포메이트
CAS 784157-49-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-688 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-α-시클로헥실벤질(N,N,N',N'테트라에칠)트리메칠렌디아민(페네타민)
CAS 3590-16-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-559 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-나프톨
CAS 135-19-3 · EC 205-182-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-20 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로-N-하이드록시에칠-p-아니시딘 및 그 염류
CAS 57524-53-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-니트로-N-하이드록시에칠-p-아니시딘
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-81 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로-p-페닐렌디아민 및 그 염류(예 : 니트로-p-페닐렌디아민 설페이트)
CAS 5307-14-2; 18266-52-9 · EC 226-164-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-니트로-p-페닐렌디아민2-니트로-p-페닐렌디아민디하이드로클로라이드
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-72 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로나프탈렌
CAS 581-89-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-55 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로아니솔
CAS 91-23-6
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-64 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로톨루엔
CAS 88-72-2
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-67 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-니트로프로판
CAS 79-46-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-79 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-디에칠아미노에칠-3-히드록시-4-페닐벤조에이트 및 그 염류
CAS 3572-52-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-디에칠아미노에칠-3-히드록시-4-페닐벤조에이트
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-200 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메칠-5-히드록시에칠아미노페놀
CAS 55302-96-0 · EC 259-583-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 산화염모제에 0.5% · 기타 제품에는 사용금지
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-174 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메칠-m-페닐렌 디이소시아네이트
CAS 91-08-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-312 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메칠레조시놀
CAS 608-25-3 · EC 210-155-8
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 산화염모제에 0.5% · 기타 제품에는 사용금지
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-207 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메칠아지리딘(프로필렌이민)
CAS 75-55-8
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-299 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메칠헵틸아민 및 그 염류
CAS 540-43-2
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-메칠헵틸아민
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-318 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시-4-니트로페놀(4-니트로구아이아콜) 및 그 염류
CAS 3251-56-7 · EC 221-839-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-메톡시-4-니트로페놀(4-니트로구아이아콜)
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-326 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시메칠-p-아미노페놀 및 그 염산염
CAS 29785-47-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-메톡시메칠-p-아미노페놀
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-332 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시에칠아세테이트(메톡시에탄올아세테이트)
CAS 110-49-6 · EC 203-772-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-338 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시에탄올(에칠렌글리콜 모노메칠에텔, EGMME)
CAS 109-86-4 · EC 203-713-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-341 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시프로판올
CAS 1589-47-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-351 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-메톡시프로필아세테이트
CAS 70657-70-4
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-352 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-부타논 옥심
CAS 96-29-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-436 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-브로모-2-나이트로프로판-1,3-디올(브로노폴)
CAS 52-51-7 · EC 200-143-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 0.1% · 아민류나 아마이드류를 함유하고 있는 제품에는 사용금지
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-44 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-브로모프로판
CAS 75-26-3
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-463 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-1,2-비스(4-메톡시페닐)에탄올 및 그 염류
CAS 530-34-7
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-아미노-1,2-비스(4-메톡시페닐)에탄올
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-598 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-3-니트로페놀 및 그 염류
CAS 603-85-0 · EC 210-060-1
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-아미노-3-니트로페놀
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-578 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-3-히드록시피리딘
CAS 16867-03-1 · EC 240-886-8
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 산화염모제에 1.0% · 기타 제품에는 사용금지
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-175 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-3-히드록시피리딘1)
CAS 16867-03-1 · EC 240-886-8
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-625 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-4-니트로페놀
CAS 99-57-0 · EC 202-767-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-579 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-5-니트로페놀
CAS 121-88-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-580 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-6-클로로-4-니트로페놀
CAS 6358-09-4 · EC 228-762-1
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a cosmetic ingredient requiring conditions of use.
Conditions : 2.0% · 기타제품에는 사용금지
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 2, record 2-239 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노-6-클로로-4-니트로페놀 및그 염류1)
CAS 6358-09-4 · EC 228-762-1
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-아미노-6-클로로-4-니트로페놀
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-611 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-아미노메칠-p-아미노페놀 및 그 염산염
CAS 79352-72-0
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-아미노메칠-p-아미노페놀
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-592 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-알칼리펜타시아노니트로실페레이트
CAS 14402-89-2; 13755-38-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-680 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-에칠헥사노익애씨드
CAS 149-57-5
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-744 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-에칠헥실[[[3,5-비스(1,1-디메칠에칠)-4-하이드록시페닐]-메칠]치오]아세테이트
CAS 80387-97-9
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-745 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-에톡시에탄올(에칠렌글리콜 모노에칠에텔, EGMEE)
CAS 110-80-5 · EC 203-804-1
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-751 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
2-클로로-5-니트로-N-하이드록시에칠-p-페닐렌디아민 및 그 염류
CAS 50610-28-1 · EC 256-652-3
Listed by the Korean MFDS as a substance that may not be used in cosmetics.
Conditions : 2-클로로-5-니트로-N-하이드록시에칠-p-페닐렌디아민
Source :화장품 안전기준 등에 관한 규정, 별표 1, record 1-898 · version 2026-19 · en vigueur 18 mars 2026 · source vérifiée 2026-08-30
Périmètre de couverture du marché
Complete current appendix dataset- Périmètre inclus
- All rows in official Appendix 1 (prohibited) and Appendix 2 (restricted) of the Safety Standards for Cosmetics.
- Si aucune correspondance n’est trouvée
- Korean source wording is canonical and other positive lists/notices may still apply to the formulation.
Liste de contrôle de vérification complète
- Match the Korean canonical substance name and identifiers.
- Review all Appendix 1 and 2 matches and conditions.
- Check functional-cosmetic and positive-list requirements where applicable.
- Confirm current MFDS notice, responsible seller and label obligations.
En quoi South Korea diffère des autres marchés
Comparaison des règles importées de ce marché avec celles de chaque autre marché pour la même substance. Un marché sans règle importée pour une substance est exclu de cette comparaison au lieu d’être considéré comme l’autorisant.
Une formule validée ailleurs peut échouer ici.
et 121 autres — voir la comparaison complète
Autorisée ici sous conditions et interdite, ou plus strictement encadrée, ailleurs — une formule conçue pour ce marché peut donc ne pas être transposable.
Sources officielles et rôle juridique
South Korea MFDS cosmetic ingredient data
Ingredient identity and separate restriction/regulation data endpoints
Signification juridique : Korean source is canonical; English materials alone are not complete enough for certification
Langue disponible : Korean with English names and CAS fields
Ce à quoi cette page de marché peut répondre
Source et autorité
Identifiez le document officiel et l’autorité de réglementation responsable : Ministry of Food and Drug Safety.
Langue et champ d’application
Voyez s’il existe un document exploitable en anglais ou bilingue et ce que couvre réellement la source cartographiée. Langue actuelle de la source : Korean with some English names.
Statut des preuves
Parcourez les fiches au niveau des ingrédients importées de sources officielles. Chaque ligne indique si elle a passé des contrôles déterministes de la source ou une relecture éditoriale humaine.
Comment vérifier un ingrédient pour ce marché
- Recherchez l’ingrédient par nom INCI, numéro CAS ou numéro CE et consignez l’identité exacte.
- Ouvrez chaque source officielle ci-dessus et vérifiez la version actuelle, le champ d’application du produit, les limites de concentration et les avertissements requis.
- Confirmez les dates d’effet et si un texte anglais est officiel, révisé ou seulement indicatif.
- Considérez l’absence de correspondance comme une inconnue, jamais comme une autorisation ni une conclusion de sécurité.