Zum Hauptinhalt springen
CosIng-Checker-Blog

What Does +/− Mean on a Makeup Ingredient List?

Veröffentlicht von Cosing Checker
• Aktualisiert

Read the plus/minus colorant group on a makeup label and learn how to confirm which pigment belongs to the shade you actually bought.

Two makeup compacts with different pigment shades on a light surface.
Two makeup compacts with different pigment shades on a light surface.

For EU decorative cosmetics marketed in several shades, Article 19 allows the colourants used across the range to be declared with “may contain” or the symbol +/−. The list is useful for identifying potential colourants across the range. Check the exact shade if you need to know whether a particular colourant is present.

Try a two-shade example

Imagine a compact lists Mica and Dimethicone, followed by +/− CI 77491, CI 77492 and CI 77499. Record the names before the symbol as declared ingredients. Record the CI numbers after the symbol as possible colourants. Keep the shade number and the country of sale with your note. Do not merge the two groups when transcribing for someone who needs shade-specific information.

What to compare between boxes

Read both cartons and confirm that they are the same product range. Identical possible-colourant lists do not establish identical pigment mixtures. If a retailer supplies one list for the whole range, compare it with the package and ask the brand for confirmation for your shade when it matters.

Use the CI number as a search term

Search the full CI number (https://cosingchecker.com/search/?q=CI+77491) including the digits. Consult the guide to EU Annex IV (https://cosingchecker.com/blogs/ci-numbers-and-eu-annex-iv-colorants/) to interpret an entry after you have identified the colourant.

Official source

EU Cosmetics Regulation, Article 19(1)(g) (https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX%3A32009R1223) Labelling conventions can differ outside the EU.

Create two lines in a shade comparison

Keep the ordinary declared ingredients on one line and the possible colorants on a second line. Add the exact shade and market. If two packages show identical possible-colorant sections, the shared section can tell you the range of possible names, while a request to the manufacturer can resolve your shade-specific question.

Example: compare two shades in the same makeup range

Suppose shades 02 and 05 both use a set of possible CI numbers after +/−. Copy the base declaration and the possible-colorants section in separate columns, then put the shade and market on each row. Compare particular shade evidence with a manufacturer response or a clearly shade-specific label. A shared list of possibilities does not show which colorants each unit contains.

For a regulatory colorant lookup, keep the complete CI number and check which application area the relevant entry describes. If the manufacturer lists a scientific name elsewhere, match the name and identifier before quoting a condition. When writing a review, say whether the declaration covers one shade or several and retain the original package photograph.

Related records and guides: Titanium Dioxide · EU Annex IV colorants.

Example: handle two lipstick shades without joining their lists

An imaginary line has a red and a coral shade. Both boxes show the same separately marked group of CI numbers. Preserve that group with the marker when transcribing each pack. Do not count a number as confirmed for the coral formula merely because it appears in the range declaration. Use the EU Annex IV colorant table to identify the relevant entries and the EU ingredient-order guide for the distinction between the main list and separately listed colorants. If you need a yes-or-no answer for one pigment, ask the brand about the current exact shade, lot and market.

Keep the shade evidence with the ingredients

Take one photograph showing the shade code and another showing the entire declaration. In your notes, mark each pigment either as named in the main list, listed for the range, or confirmed by the maker for the precise shade.

What to put in the shade column of a product comparison

Save both the shade code and the description. A shared name such as “Rose” can refer to several products, and two cartons can show the same grouped colorant declaration without identifying an individual shade’s mixture. For each number, write “declared in main list,” “in marked colorant range,” or “confirmed for this shade by the maker,” depending on the evidence. For instance, the records for CI 77491 and CI 15850 identify different colorants, not the shade formula itself. Retain the original image with the plus/minus marker so that someone can verify which words belonged to that group.

Über diesen Artikel

Dieser Artikel gehört zum Blog von CosIng Checker, in dem wir Leitfäden, Notizen und praxisnahe Erläuterungen zu kosmetischen Inhaltsstoffen der EU, Beschränkungen aus den Anhängen II–VI, Warnhinweisen, Konservierungsstoffen, UV-Filtern, Farbstoffen und verwandten Compliance-Themen veröffentlichen.